Automatic enrolment (AE) can significantly increase supplementary pension coverage across Europe, but greater participation alone will not guarantee adequate retirement outcomes, PensionsEurope has warned.
Launching its new report, Auto-enrolment in Focus: Expanding Pension Coverage Through Workplace-Based Solutions in Europe, at the PensionsEurope Annual Conference 2026 in Lisbon, the organisation called for European policymakers to strengthen workplace pension provision while ensuring that reforms reflect national circumstances and deliver sustainable retirement incomes.
It identified four main models through which European countries have expanded participation: collective bargaining and social partner-based arrangements, mandatory participation, AE, and voluntary occupational pension provision.
Presenting the findings at the conference, Eversheds Sutherland senior pensions partner, Francois Barker, acknowledged the success of AE systems, suggesting it largely stemmed from their ability to overcome the inertia that often prevents individuals from engaging with pension saving.
"It works by harnessing apathy," he explained, arguing that automatically enrolling workers while retaining their right to opt out reversed the behavioural barriers associated with voluntary pension participation.
Barker also highlighted that AE had particularly benefited groups historically less likely to participate in workplace pensions, including women, younger workers, part-time employees and lower earners.
However, he warned that simply increasing participation was insufficient to address retirement adequacy.
"Participation is just the start of the journey," he noted, stressing that contribution levels, investment performance, charges, governance and the eventual income delivered to retirees were equally important.
Reflecting on the UK's experience, Barker identified three key lessons for European countries considering AE.
"The first is that quality matters," he stated, warning that automatically enrolling workers into poor-quality pension arrangements could undermine retirement outcomes.
He also highlighted the challenges created by increasingly fragmented working lives, with individuals potentially accumulating numerous pension pots as they change employers.
"People may end up with 10 or 12 different pots from being automatically enrolled by 10 or 12 different employers," he explained.
"That's messy and expensive, and you need a system to consolidate them."
The third challenge concerned decumulation, with Barker warning that DC-based AE systems needed mechanisms to convert accumulated savings into sustainable retirement income.
"All that creates is a big pot of money at the end. It doesn't create a pension. It doesn't create a retirement income," he argued.
These concerns were reflected in the report's eight policy recommendations, which called for retirement adequacy to be placed at the centre of pension reform, alongside the expansion of workplace pension coverage.
Indeed, PensionsEurope urged policymakers to ensure appropriate contribution levels, cost-effective investment strategies, effective governance and sustainable retirement income solutions, while recognising the importance of existing national pension arrangements and social partner structures.
It also recommended proportionate administrative requirements for employers, supported by digital infrastructure and clear implementation frameworks, particularly to reduce the burden on smaller businesses.
The report highlighted the importance of addressing gaps among self-employed workers and those with non-standard employment patterns, warning that workplace-based AE systems could leave some groups outside pension provision.
It also emphasised the role of pension tracking systems in helping individuals understand their entitlements across different employers and pension arrangements, while noting that improved visibility would not, by itself, resolve fragmented pension saving.
In addition, PensionsEurope stressed that while supplementary pension assets could contribute to the objectives of the Savings and Investments Union (SIU), investment decisions must remain focused on members' long-term interests rather than broader European economic objectives.
The organisation called for stable regulatory and tax frameworks to maintain confidence in supplementary pensions, alongside reforms that consider the entire retirement journey from enrolment and accumulation through to decumulation.
Barker similarly stressed the importance of long-term political consensus, suggesting that the UK's AE system had survived successive changes of government because it was developed with broad support from employers, trade unions and policymakers.
However, he acknowledged that AE was not a complete solution, particularly for self-employed workers and those with irregular employment histories, while effective enforcement would also be necessary to ensure employers met their obligations.
Echoing this, PensionsEurope Standing Committee on the Future of Pensions chair, Klaus Stiefermann, reinforced the importance of respecting national differences, stressing in the report's foreword that Europe did not need "uniformity" to make progress.
Instead, the report argued that policymakers should focus on identifying participation mechanisms that complement existing national systems, while ensuring that greater pension coverage ultimately translates into adequate and sustainable retirement incomes.
PensionsEurope CEO, Matti Leppälä, concluded: "What ultimately matters is not only how many people participate, but whether pension systems deliver adequate and sustainable retirement incomes."








Recent Stories